Wood vs Vinyl Fence: The Ultimate Buying Guide

Think about the primary objective for your fence. If you want privacy, opt for tall solid wood or vinyl fences. If security is a concern, wrought-iron fences and wood fences with barbed wire are the safest. For containing pet, consider mesh fences or sturdy wood fences. To establish property lines, shorter fences made of plywood or vinyl will be adequate. With children around, safety is always a concern. Vinyl fences with a gate are a great choice to safeguard a pool.

When purchasing a fence, consider its upkeep requirements. Vinyl fences are easier to maintain as they don't need regular sealing, staining, or painting. However, wood fences require these treatments typically every two years to prevent rot and deterioration.

However, vinyl fences tend to show dirt and will need frequent cleaning. This can easily be managed with a pressure washer.

Overall, both require some maintenance but of different kinds. Vinyl requires more frequent cleaning, while wood requires more treatments.

Wood fences have a lot more character and versatility. There are numerous styles, colors and finishes which can be left natural, hued or painted. Wood will have some natural imperfections from knots and grains which add to its rustic feel.

Vinyl used to have a very plastic-like appearance, but its visual appeal has improved in recent years. There are some great faux-wood options that have really elevated the style of vinyl fencing. These PVC planks are mass produced so there aren’t as many design options as compared to wood.

You could occasionally change the look of a wood fence with different stains or paints if you want to revamp the look of your fence. You can't alter the appearance of vinyl. If you prefer a smooth design and flawless finish, a vinyl fence is your best choice.

Wood fences can last around 20 years. But it will rot or warp over time and need repair or replacement. Cedar is naturally rot-resistant and can last up to 30 years, while pressure-treated pine is more affordable but might only last 15 years. Wood fences in wet climates will deteriorate faster than those in dry areas.

The biggest advantage of vinyl fencing is durability. Vinyl can easily last for decades, withstanding harsh weather, pests, fungus and decay. Keep in mind that vinyl fences are harder to fix when problems arise. A broken piece would require that you replace the entire panel. With wood, you can just replace the individual plank. If your fence has cracks, they will be simpler to repair if it’s wood. Wood filler can be used to mend a wooden fence, making it a simple DIY task.

Vinyl is much more durable and can withstand wear and tear. Wood is more easily damaged but it is also easier to replace.

While budgeting for a home, you must consider the investment on the front end as well as the long term costs. Wood fences are more affordable than vinyl ones. While the initial buy is more expensive, vinyl is cost-effective in the long run. Vinyl fences are easier to maintain while wood will need repair or replacement. The area you need to cover will be a big determinant as well. Installation costs for wood fences are cheaper but they tend to take 2-4 days to put up. Vinyl fences can be installed on one day but the installation charge may be comparatively pricier.

For short term or smaller scale projects, wood fences are adequate. In the long run, vinyl fences prove to be more economical.