Prices, Promotions, styles, and availability may vary. Our local stores do not honor online pricing. Prices and availability of products and services are subject to change without notice. Errors will be corrected where discovered, and Lowe's reserves the right to revoke any stated offer and to correct any errors, inaccuracies or omissions including after an order has been submitted.

Water Heater vs. Boiler: What to Choose?

Lowe's Editorial Team

By Lowe's Editorial Team
Published February 12, 2025

The debate of a water heater vs a boiler comes up when heating water for your home. Both appliances provide hot water. However, they function differently and are intended for various purposes. Understanding their key features can help you make the right choice for your home.

What is a Boiler

You might wonder whether a boiler is a water heater, but a boiler offers more functionality. A boiler provides hot water for domestic tasks like bathing and washing and serves as a heating system for your home. It distributes heat through radiators or underfloor heating.

This dual-purpose system makes boilers an ideal choice if you need hot water and centralized heating. Boilers can operate on various energy sources, including gas, oil, electricity or even biomass. It gives you flexibility in choosing a system that suits your needs.

Types of Boilers

Boilers are categorized into two main types. Each is designed for different household requirements:

1. Combination Boilers (Combi Boilers):
These compact units provide both heating and hot water on demand without the need for a separate storage tank. They are ideal for smaller homes or apartments with limited space and moderate hot water needs. Combi boilers are energy-efficient because they heat water only when needed. It reduces energy wastage.

2. System Boilers:
These boilers include a storage tank that stores hot water. Making them suitable for larger homes with higher hot water demands. A system boiler ensures that multiple taps or showers can run simultaneously without a drop in water pressure. Making it a practical option for busy households.

Use of Boiler

Boilers are highly versatile and serve multiple purposes:

  1. Domestic hot water: They provide hot water for everyday activities like bathing, washing and cooking.
  2. Space heating: Boilers are integral to central heating systems. It distributes heat through radiators or underfloor heating to maintain a warm indoor environment.
  3. Specialized heating: Some boilers are used for industrial or commercial applications. It includes heating large buildings or processing facilities.

Cons of Boilers

Here are some cons of boilers:

  1. Boilers are more expensive to install compared to standard water heaters. Especially for system boilers that require additional components like storage tanks.
  2. System boilers with storage tanks require more space. It may not be suitable for smaller homes.
  3. Boilers require regular servicing to ensure safety and efficiency, particularly for older models or those using gas or oil.
  4. Repairing a boiler can be more complicated and costly than fixing a water heater.

What is a Water Heater

A water heater is a device designed to heat water for household use. Whether it’s for taking a hot shower, washing dishes, or doing laundry. A water heater ensures a steady supply of hot water to meet your daily needs. Unlike boilers, water heaters are not designed to provide home heating. Their sole function is to deliver heated water for domestic purposes.

Water heaters are widely used because of their simplicity, affordability and efficiency. Depending on the type, they can heat water and store it for later use or heat it instantly when needed. They are especially suitable for homes where hot water is needed solely for basic household activities and not for heating the living space.

Types of Water Heaters

Water heaters come in two main types. Each has unique features and advantages:

1. Tank water heaters:
These traditional water heaters store and heat large amounts of water in an insulated tank. It keeps the water hot and ready for use. The tank refills and reheats as water is used. It is ideal for households with consistent hot water demands. However, they occupy more space and may run out of hot water during heavy usage until the tank reheats. 

2. Tankless water heaters:
Also known as on-demand water heaters, these heat water only when needed. They do not store hot water, which makes them more compact and energy-efficient. Tankless water heaters are ideal for smaller homes or those with limited hot water needs. However, they may struggle to supply hot water to multiple outlets simultaneously in larger households.

Use of Water Heaters

Water heaters are essential for various domestic tasks, including:

  1. For the shower: Water heaters provide comfortable hot water for bathing.
  2. Dishwashing: It provides hot water to ensure clean and sanitized dishes.
  3. Laundry: Water heaters supply warm water for effective washing. Particularly for delicate fabrics or tough stains.
  4. Cooking: The hot water from the water heater helps in kitchen tasks like cleaning or quick hot water needs.

Cons of Water Heater

  1. Unlike boilers, water heaters do not provide space heating. It limits their usefulness in cold climates.
  2. Tank water heaters can run out of hot water during heavy usage. It requires time to reheat the tank. 
  3. Tankless water heaters can have a higher upfront cost compared to traditional tank models.
  4. Tankless water heaters may struggle to supply hot water to multiple outlets at the same time. Especially in larger households.
  5. Tank water heaters continuously heat the stored water. Leading to standby energy loss, even when not in use.

The Key Differences: Water Heater Vs Boiler

An image explaining the Key Differences between water heater and boiler.

Difference Between Water Heater Vs Boiler

When deciding between a water heater and a boiler for your home, it is important to consider a few factors. Below is a detailed comparison of these two systems to help you make an informed decision.

1. Lifespan:
Water heaters vs boilers typically last 8-12 years for tank models and 20 years or more for tankless models. The lifespan completely depends on maintenance and usage. Over time, sediment buildup in tank water heaters can reduce efficiency and lifespan if not cleaned regularly.

Boilers generally have a longer lifespan ranging from 15-25 years. They are built to handle higher pressure and temperatures. It contributes to their durability, but regular servicing is critical to keep them running smoothly.

2. Installation:
Water heaters are simpler and quicker to install. Especially tank models. They typically require a smaller upfront cost for installation. Their compact size makes them easy to place in tight spaces. However, tankless models may require additional electrical or gas line upgrades.

Installing a boiler is more complex and time-consuming. It requires a network of pipes for radiators or underfloor heating systems. The process is more expensive and typically involves professional assistance due to the system's intricacies.

3. Maintenance: 
Maintenance of water heaters is straightforward. For tank models, regular flushing is required to remove sediment buildup. While the anode rod should be inspected and replaced if necessary. Tankless models require descaling to prevent mineral buildup in areas with hard water.

Boilers require more intensive and frequent maintenance. Tasks include checking pressure, cleaning components like the heat exchanger and inspecting the system for leaks or corrosion. Professional servicing is often recommended for boilers to ensure optimal performance and safety.

4. Sustainability: 
Modern water heaters are designed to be energy-efficient. Tankless water heaters heat water on demand, reducing energy waste. However, traditional water heaters can lose energy through standby heat loss.

Boilers are generally more energy-efficient for homes that need both hot water and heating. High-efficiency condensing boilers recycle heat from exhaust gases. It lowers energy consumption and emissions. However, their larger energy requirements can make them less sustainable in milder climates where heating is minimal.

5. Cost:
Water heaters are more affordable upfront. Tank models cost $500–$1,500, including installation. Meanwhile, tankless models range from $1,500 to $3,000. Their simpler design and easier installation contribute to their lower price.

Boilers are more expensive, with costs ranging from $3,000–$8,000 or more, including installation. The higher price is due to the complexity of the system and the dual functionality of both heating home and hot water.

Which Should You Choose

When deciding between a water heater vs a boiler, consider your specific needs:

  1. Choose a water heater if: You only need hot water for daily tasks like showers, washing dishes or doing laundry. Water heaters are budget-friendly and simple to maintain. 
  2. Choose a boiler if: Your home also requires a heating system, such as radiators or underfloor heating. Boilers are a great long-term investment for homes in colder or larger households with high heating and water demands.

The decision between a water heater vs boiler ultimately depends on your home’s hot water and heating needs. While a water heater is perfect for basic water heating, a boiler offers a comprehensive solution by providing both hot water and home heating. Evaluate your budget, energy consumption and household size before making your choice. 

Related Tags: